ireadkidsbooks

Photo Post
I don’t want to sound presumptuous, but I think it’s safe to say that most of us are pretty familiar with Walt Disney’s synergized version of The Little Mermaid as opposed to Hans Christian Andersen’s original version. I also think that most will agree that Walt Disney’s version is a corporate appropriation of the original - which Walt Disney film isn’t, right? In any case, both merit discussion since they inadvertently find themselves at opposite ends of the spectrum. I’m not going to go into detail about each version, you’ll have to do the leg work on that one yourselves. However, if you’ve seen Walt Disney’s The Little Mermaid, then you’re half way there. I will say that as a scholar I feel a respsonsibility to introduce Hans Christian Andersen’s original version of The Little Mermaid. As an educator, I feel quite the opposite. For example, I think Hans Christian Andersen’s version should wait on deck, so to speak, until children are old enough to understand and as a result, appreciate the complexity of the original version.

I don’t want to sound presumptuous, but I think it’s safe to say that most of us are pretty familiar with Walt Disney’s synergized version of The Little Mermaid as opposed to Hans Christian Andersen’s original version. I also think that most will agree that Walt Disney’s version is a corporate appropriation of the original - which Walt Disney film isn’t, right? In any case, both merit discussion since they inadvertently find themselves at opposite ends of the spectrum. I’m not going to go into detail about each version, you’ll have to do the leg work on that one yourselves. However, if you’ve seen Walt Disney’s The Little Mermaid, then you’re half way there. I will say that as a scholar I feel a respsonsibility to introduce Hans Christian Andersen’s original version of The Little Mermaid. As an educator, I feel quite the opposite. For example, I think Hans Christian Andersen’s version should wait on deck, so to speak, until children are old enough to understand and as a result, appreciate the complexity of the original version.

Posted on Wednesday, May 20, 2009.
6
Notes
  1. junpoco liked this
  2. hiddenlabyrinth reblogged this from rainbowmummies and added:
    Hehe. Its SOOO true! Disney has made some “classics”…. but in reality…the stories they are based on are dark, twisted...
  3. hiddenlabyrinth liked this
  4. rainbowmummies reblogged this from ireadkidsbooks and added:
    jess, aka hiddenlabyrinth ireadkidsbooks:
  5. mrscupcakeman liked this
  6. ireadkidsbooks posted this
ireadkidsbooks I read kids books is what I do. It's just me, reading kids books and writing my thoughts. I have a M.Ed. in Children's Literature, so in my years of researching children’s literature, I’ve found that children’s literature is essential to the personal and academic development of all children because it is a window that not only opens, but also reflects the diversity of our human experience. More importantly, it lets young readers and readers of all ages know that children and people like them are worthy of being in books. If you have any questions, comments, observations, or if you just want to say hello, send me an email.
Previous Next